The auction: why price moves
For most of the trading day the exchange operates as a continuous double auction: buyers and sellers place and cancel orders at any moment, and the matching engine immediately matches those that are compatible on price. This is a practice-level lesson: which events change the order book, why the quote can change without a single trade, what actually moves price, and how the opening auction differs from continuous trading.
Three events that make up trading
Everything that happens in the order book comes down to three events:
- A new order. A limit order that finds no counterpart rests in the book; one that is compatible on price executes immediately, in full or in part, and the remainder rests in the book.
- Canceling or modifying an order. A participant cancels an order or moves it to another price; a moved order loses its place in the queue.
- A trade. An incoming order executes against resting ones; the levels it takes out completely disappear.
Trades are visible on the tape, changes to the book — in the order book. The first two events create no trades, but they change what the next aggressive order will meet. Most of what you see in the order book of a liquid instrument is the constant movement of limit orders, not trades.
Price-time priority
The book is ordered by two rules (details in the lesson How price is formed): the best price executes first, and at the same price, the order that arrived earlier. This has practical consequences.
- Queue position is a resource. A limit order placed at a level in advance will execute before orders that arrive later at the same price. Liquidity providers compete for queue position, and moving an order sends it to the back of the queue.
- Whether a limit order fills depends on what stands in front of it. If 5,000 lots stand ahead of your 10 lots at a level, aggressive opposing orders have to “eat” 5,000 lots before they reach you — or those orders have to be canceled.
- Price touching your level does not mean a fill. If price reached your level and left, and the tape showed trades at your price, your order may still be unfilled: the queue in front of it did not run out.
The quote changes without trades
The best bid and best ask change not only because of trades. If all sellers at the best price cancel their orders, the ask moves up to the next level without a single trade. If someone places a buy order inside the spread, the bid rises — also without a trade.
So the movement of the quote and the movement of trade prices are different things. In a quiet market quotes can move while there are almost no trades; on a chart built from trades such a move shows up only when the next trade prints — often several ticks at once.
Every trade has two sides
“Price rises because there are more buyers than sellers” explains nothing: in every trade exactly as much is bought as is sold. If 10,000 lots traded in a minute, then 10,000 lots were bought and 10,000 were sold. What differs is something else:
- who was the aggressor — arrived and executed immediately (see How price is formed);
- how much passive liquidity stands in the way of aggressive orders;
- what happens to limit orders — they are added, canceled, moved.
Trade prices rise when aggressive buying fills all sell orders at the best price and moves on to the next level, or when sellers themselves move their orders up. They fall in the opposite case. The excess of aggressive buying or selling within a bar is called delta — aggressive buy volume minus aggressive sell volume.
The same flow, different moves
Below are two order books and the same market buy — 300 lots. In the first there are few sellers at the nearby levels, in the second there are many.
Thin order book:
Levels the order took in full disappear; a level taken in part stays with what is left.
Deep order book:
Levels the order took in full disappear; a level taken in part stays with what is left.
In the thin book the buy takes out five levels entirely and part of the sixth, and the best ask rises by five ticks; in the deep book it takes a third of the best level, and the ask does not change. In both cases the trades are “buys at the ask” for 300 lots; the whole difference is on the passive side. That is why the tape and delta are read together with the order book: the tape shows the push, the book shows how much stands against it.
Why strong buying may not move price
If there is a lot of aggressive buying while price stands still or falls, the buys were executing against sell orders and the sellers did not run out. This happens when:
- a large volume or an iceberg order sits at the best price;
- the level is replenished — by new sellers or by a liquidity provider who re-places the order after each trade;
- sellers who wanted to exit positions use the buying flow as a chance to sell;
- price had already moved earlier, and the buying is “catching up” with it.
The “strong delta without price movement” situation is called absorption: the aggressive flow is absorbed by passive liquidity. It is one of the most useful pictures for a scalper: it shows where a strong opposing side stands in price’s way. A single sign is a reason to take a closer look; read it together with the level, the market regime and your risk. Details — the lesson Absorption and exhaustion.
Why price can move without a large delta
The opposite situation is common too. Trade prices can move several ticks on a small delta if:
- the order book is thin — a little aggressive volume walks through several levels;
- liquidity providers pulled their orders — the quote moved without trades, and the next trade printed at the new price;
- news came out — participants re-placed their orders at once, and the market “jumped” to a new level.
Hidden liquidity: iceberg orders
MOEX has iceberg orders: only part of the volume is visible in the order book, and once it is filled, the next portion is placed (description of the evening session modes ). On the tape it looks like this: far more trades go through at one price than was visible in the order book, yet the level does not disappear.
Executed volume at a price that is noticeably larger than the visible volume is the main sign of an iceberg. A similar picture arises when several participants take turns placing new orders at the same price, or when a liquidity provider replenishes the level after each trade. For trading, what matters more is this: more stands at that price than is visible, and it is holding the push.
The opening auction
At the start of a session the exchange does not launch continuous trading right away but holds an opening auction. For a few minutes orders are only collected and there are no trades; the exchange shows the indicative price — the price at which trades would happen if the auction ended now. At the end, the price at which the largest volume can be matched is chosen, and all compatible orders execute at that single price (MOEX presentation on the auction ).
The auction solves a specific problem: in the first seconds after a break there are few orders, and one random order could set the opening price far from where the bulk of buyers and sellers meet. For a trader this has two consequences: the opening price is the result of supply and demand accumulated during the break, and the first continuous trading after the auction often runs with a wide spread until the order book fills up again.
In the JetScalp terminal
- You see orders in the order book and trades on the tape at the same time in the order book window — Order book area and Tape area. The order book can highlight large volumes and icebergs — Order book tab.
- The Delta indicator shows delta per bar, and the Footprint chart type shows aggressive buying and selling at each price inside the bar; absorption marks on bars — Bar signals.
- How to place orders in the opening auction — Auction.
Summary
- Trading is a stream of new orders, cancellations and trades; trades are the smaller share of order book events.
- Price-time priority makes queue position a resource: price touching your level does not mean a fill.
- The quote changes without trades too — when orders are canceled and when new orders appear inside the spread.
- Bought volume always equals sold volume; price is moved by the aggressor against the passive liquidity in its way, so the same flow moves price by different amounts.
- Strong delta without movement is absorption: a reason to look closer at the level, not a signal on its own.
- The opening auction collects orders without trades and executes them at the single price of maximum volume.
Check yourself
- Why might your limit buy order at 100.00 not have filled even though trades went through at 100.00 on the tape?
- How can the best ask rise by two ticks if there were no trades during that time?
- Why doesn’t “there are more buyers than sellers” explain a price rise?
- What explanations are there for a bar with strong positive delta that closed below the previous one?