Trading plan and journal
Decisions made before a trade are almost always better than decisions made during it: while the position is open, hope and fear press on every choice. This is a basics-level lesson: what to put in a trading plan, what to record in the journal for each trade, and how to tell from the journal whether what you are doing works. How a strategy is built as a set of rules is covered in the lesson Anatomy of a strategy.
Important: The sample plan in this lesson is a teaching example, not a recommendation of what to buy and when. Any entry requires a stop-loss and a position size calculated from risk (Risk and position size).
Trading plan
A plan is a set of rules that you can follow and later check. Another person would carry out a good rule exactly as you do. “I buy on a strong move” is not a rule; “I buy after a 5-minute bar closes above the 10:00–10:30 high, with the stop below the low of that range” is a rule.
What goes into the plan:
- Market and instruments — what you trade and why (the lesson How to choose an instrument).
- Time — the hours when you trade and when you do not: for example, you do not open positions a few minutes before major news.
- Setups — exact entry conditions for each one.
- Exit — a stop loss set before the entry, conditions for taking profit or for a time-based exit.
- Position size — derived from the risk per trade and the distance to the stop (the lesson Risk and position size).
- Limits — the maximum loss per day and per week after which you stop trading; the maximum number of trades per day.
- When not to trade — after a losing streak, when you are not in good shape, on an instrument with an unusually wide spread.
An example of the form, not a strategy recommendation: instrument Si; time 10:00–18:30; entry — a breakout of the 10:00–10:30 range on a 5-minute bar close; stop — the opposite boundary of the range; exit — at 18:30 or at the stop; risk — 1% of capital; after two stops in a day, trading ends for the day.
Trading journal
One entry per trade:
| Field | Why |
|---|---|
| Date, time, instrument | Tie the trade to a time and a market |
| Setup from the plan | Count the result for each setup separately |
| Entry, stop, target | See whether the plan was followed |
| Size and risk in money | Convert the result into units of risk |
| Exit and its reason | Tell an exit by the rule from an exit out of fear |
| Result in money and in R | Compare trades of different sizes |
| Costs | See how much fees and slippage take |
| Chart screenshot | Review the trade later without relying on your memory of “how it was” |
| Deviation from the plan | Find execution mistakes |
R is the result in units of risk: the profit or loss divided by the trade’s risk. A trade with a risk of RUB 2,000 and a profit of RUB 3,000 is +1.5 R (the lesson Risk and position size).
Review
Once a week or once every few dozen trades:
- Sum and average in R — the expectancy of a trade for each setup.
- Share of trades by the plan — how many trades fully followed the rules. Count the result of off-plan trades separately.
- Costs — what share of the result went to fees and slippage.
- Mistakes — what keeps repeating: late entries, a moved stop, trades after the loss limit.
How many trades you need for conclusions. Ten trades are not enough: even a rule with a positive expectancy has long losing streaks, and a random one has winning streaks. A reliable estimate takes hundreds of trades. That is why rules are not changed after two or three bad days — they are changed when the review shows a persistent cause.
In the JetScalp terminal
Closed trades, the cumulative result and filtering by connection, account and instrument are in the Statistics window; filled orders are in the Trades table. The levels from the plan can be marked in advance with alert levels in the order book or on the chart. Alert levels live in the cloud: when the price reaches a level, you get a push on your phone and a Telegram message (if Telegram is linked to your account) even with the terminal closed — no need to watch the screen all day (Alerts). A window layout for your plan — lesson Trader’s workspace.
Summary
- A plan is rules you can execute and check: instruments, time, entry, exit, size, loss limits.
- A journal is an entry for every trade, including the exit reason, the result in R, costs and deviations from the plan.
- A review is the average R by setup, the share of trades by the plan, costs and repeating mistakes.
- Conclusions about a rule come from hundreds of trades, not from a few days.
Check yourself
- Rewrite “I buy when the price bounces off a level” so that the rule is always executed the same way.
- A trade with a risk of RUB 1,500 closed with a loss of RUB 2,250. How much is that in R, and what could have gone against the plan?
- Why is it worth counting the result of off-plan trades separately?