Execution and trade cost
The same idea can cost different amounts at entry and exit: a market order pays the spread and the taker fee, a limit order may not fill, and the time of day changes both. This is a basics-level lesson: practical execution rules, what the full cost of a trade consists of and how many trades must be winners just to break even. Good execution saves money on every trade — especially in scalping.
Important: This lesson covers how to execute a trade, not which trade to open. The numbers in the examples are illustrative; check the fees with your broker and exchange.
Market or limit order
- A market order fills immediately but pays the spread, the taker fee and slippage if the size is larger than the best order.
- A limit order does not pay the spread, and the maker fee is usually lower than the taker fee (lessons Fees and taxes on the Moscow Exchange and Fees and orders on a crypto exchange). But it may not fill, and it most often fills when the price moves against it: a buy at the best bid fills if sellers push the price down, and stays in the book if the price rises.
A practical rule: enter with a limit order when you do not mind missing the trade; exit at the stop with a market order, because a missed exit costs more than the spread. How orders queue and fill is covered in the lesson The order book.
Time of day
Liquidity is spread unevenly over the day. On the Moscow Exchange most trades happen in the first hours of the main session and the fewest in the morning before 10:00 and late in the evening; on a crypto exchange liquidity also changes during the day and at weekends. In quiet hours the spread is wider and the price moves in jerks — orders fill worse. Illiquid securities are especially sensitive to the time: trade them in hours when the order book has volume.
Do not chase the price
After a large aggressive buy or a sharp spike, it is tempting to buy right after with a market order. Such an order pays the spread and often slippage — at prices that have already moved. It is wiser to decide on the entry in advance and place a limit order at a level, or to wait for a pullback. Large trades and bursts on the tape are a reason to take a closer look; read them together with the level, the market regime and the risk (lessons Large trades and Absorption and exhaustion).
Stop orders in a fast market
A stop order becomes a market order when the price reaches the level, and it fills at whatever prices are in the order book. In a fast market that is worse than the stop level:
- on Moscow Exchange stocks a sharp move triggers a discrete auction, and continuous trading stops (lesson Moscow Exchange stock market);
- for futures the price hits the daily limit, and it may be impossible to close the position (lesson Moscow Exchange dated futures);
- on a crypto exchange a stop can trigger on the last price or on the mark price, and price protection keeps a market order from going too far (lesson Fees and orders on a crypto exchange).
A stop closer than the typical one-minute move will be hit by ordinary noise (lesson Style and instrument).
A large position
If the order size is comparable to the volume of the several best levels of the order book, a market order will sweep through them and move the price against you. Compare the size with the book depth and, if needed, split the position into parts over time or place limit orders at several levels (lesson Liquidity and market impact).
The full cost of a trade
A trade costs more than the commission in the fee schedule: the spread, slippage and the cost of carrying the position are added. Entry plus exit together is called a round trip.
| Component | When it is paid |
|---|---|
| Spread | On entry or exit with a market order |
| Exchange fee | On every trade; for a maker usually lower or zero |
| Broker’s commission | On every trade, per the broker’s fee schedule |
| Slippage | When the size exceeds the best level or the price has moved |
| Carry and funding | For every night with leverage or every funding charge |
Examples
The numbers are illustrative — orders of magnitude, not fee schedules.
A stock. 100 shares at RUB 290 — a RUB 29,000 position. An exchange taker fee of about 0.03% per side is about RUB 9 at entry and the same at exit; a one-tick spread is RUB 1. In total about RUB 19, or 6–7 bp excluding the broker’s commission.
A futures contract. One liquid contract worth RUB 84,000. The exchange taker fee is thousandths of a percent, about RUB 4 per side; a one-tick spread is RUB 1. In total about RUB 9, or about 1 bp, plus the broker’s commission per contract.
A perpetual contract on a crypto exchange. 0.1 BTC at 64,000 USDT — a 6,400 USDT position, held for three days. A taker fee of about 0.05% at entry and exit is 6.40 USDT; funding of 0.01% per 8 hours, nine charges, is about 5.80 USDT. In total about 12 USDT, or 19 bp: over a few days funding is comparable to the commission.
Calculate your own trade:
A round trip is an entry and an exit with market orders: the fees on both sides, the spread once, the slippage on both sides. The default exchange fee is the taker fee on the lesson's date; put in your broker's fee.
Carrying a position
- A margin position on the Moscow Exchange: an interest-bearing loan from the broker — check the rate in the fee schedule (lesson Risk rates and margin on the Moscow Exchange).
- A futures contract: there is no carry fee, but it is built into the contract price — the basis; when rolling into a new contract you pay two spreads and two commissions (lesson Moscow Exchange dated futures).
- A perpetual contract: funding — once a day on the Moscow Exchange, usually every 8, 4 or 1 hours on crypto exchanges (lesson Perpetual contracts on crypto exchanges).
Breakeven point
A winning trade brings the target minus the round trip; a losing one loses the stop plus the round trip. So breaking even requires a share of winning trades of (stop + round trip) / (target + stop). Without costs, with the target equal to the stop, half the trades being winners is enough. With costs you need more:
| Target and stop | Round trip 7 bp | Round trip 2 bp |
|---|---|---|
| 10 / 10 bp | 85% | 60% |
| 20 / 20 bp | 68% | 55% |
| 50 / 50 bp | 57% | 52% |
| 100 / 100 bp | 54% | 51% |
Hence the rule: the shorter the target, the cheaper the round trip must be. A scalper aiming for a few ticks works on liquid instruments with a 1–2 bp round trip and enters with limit orders — that is what makes short targets workable. Cutting costs matters as much as finding good entries.
More: the breakeven formula
Let the target be bp, the stop bp and the round trip bp. A winning trade brings , a losing one loses . The expectancy is zero at a share of winning trades of
More on the mathematics of expectancy — lesson Risk and position size.
In the JetScalp terminal
Limit and market orders, stop-loss and take-profit are placed from the order book and from the chart (Trading from the order book). The order book shows the order volume at each level as a histogram — it shows how much a market order can absorb (Order book area); the tape filter picks out large trades (Tape). The position panel shows the average entry price and breakeven (Position in the order book); for perpetual contracts there is a funding badge with the rate, the time to the next charge and the expected payment (Funding). The result of closed trades is in the Statistics window.
Summary
- A market order guarantees a fill for the spread and the taker fee; a limit order saves money but more often fills against you. Exit at the stop with a market order.
- Trade in liquid hours and do not chase the price with a market order — decide on the entry in advance.
- In a fast market a stop fills worse than its level, and on Moscow Exchange stocks and futures trading can stop.
- The full cost is the spread, fees and commissions, slippage, carry or funding.
- The share of winning trades needed to break even is (stop + round trip) / (target + stop): short targets need a cheap round trip.
Check yourself
- Why does a limit buy order more often fill when the price is falling?
- What happens to a stop order on a stock when a discrete auction starts?
- Target 30 bp, stop 15 bp, round trip 3 bp. What share of winning trades is needed to break even?
- You hold a perpetual contract for a week at a funding rate of 0.01% per 8 hours. How much is that as a percentage of the position?