Skip to Content
StrategiesAnatomy of a strategy

Anatomy of a strategy

A strategy is a set of rules by which you make the same trades in the same situations. As long as a decision depends on mood, it can be neither repeated nor improved. This is a practice-level lesson: what parts a strategy consists of, how to match an approach to the market regime and how to keep a journal.

Important: This lesson explains how rules are built, not which trade to open. Every entry needs a stop loss and a position size calculated from risk.

What a strategy consists of

Diagram of eight blocks: idea, conditions, signal, entry, risk, exit, costs, testing
The eight parts of a strategy: from the idea to testing.
  1. Idea — why the move should happen. A good idea names the participants: who will buy or sell and why. “Price will bounce off the level” becomes an idea once it says who will buy at the level — for example, those who already bought there yesterday.
  2. Conditions — where and when the rule applies: instrument, time of day, market regime (see Market regime filter).
  3. Signal — an exact rule on a closed bar: “a one-minute close above the range high”, not “price broke the level”. A signal on a forming bar can disappear before the close (lesson What indicators measure).
  4. Entry — with which order type. A market order fills at once but pays the spread and the taker fee; a limit order is cheaper but may not fill if price moves away immediately.
  5. Risk — stop loss and position size. The stop loss goes where the idea stops being valid; the position size is chosen so that the loss at the stop is a preset share of the account (lesson Risk and position size).
  6. Exit — a target, a time or a rule: “at the opposite boundary”, “after 30 minutes”, “by a trailing stop”. The exit shapes the result as much as the entry.
  7. Costs — exchange and broker fees, spread, slippage (see Costs).
  8. Testing — how the rule behaved on history and in your own trades: journal entries, review on the chart.

Market regime filter

Approaches work in different conditions: trend rules lose in chop, trades from range boundaries lose in a strong trend. So before a trade it helps to answer one question: what is the regime now? (lesson Market regimes).

RegimeWhat it looks likeWhich approach fits
TrendPrice stays on one side of the average and VWAP, highs and lows shift one way, VWAP slopes.Trend and pullbacks, continuation after a breakout.
RangePrice crosses the average back and forth, bounces off the same boundaries, VWAP is almost flat.Ranges and mean reversion, the volume profile.
SqueezeThe bar range narrows, the Bollinger Bands move inside the Keltner Channel.Preparing for a breakout: boundaries and alerts in advance.

Regime indicators make the call less subjective:

  • EfficiencyRatio — the “efficiency” of a move, from 0 (back and forth) to 1 (a straight line);
  • Choppiness — near 100 is chop, near 0 is a smooth trend;
  • VwapDeviation — the VWAP slope: whether the day trends or price moves around VWAP;
  • Squeeze — marks a volatility squeeze before a possible breakout.

A regime filter is not an on/off switch but one more reason to take a closer look. The regime changes during the day, and a measure over past bars describes a move that has already happened. Set the filter in advance, in your trading plan, and do not tune the threshold to your last few trades.

More: why a filter must not be tuned on history

If you try many measures, thresholds and periods on the same history, one of the combinations will almost certainly “work” — purely by chance. On new data such a combination usually behaves differently. The honest order: write the filter down before testing, based on the idea; test it on data that played no part in inventing it; remember that a filter splits trades into groups, and each group has fewer trades — so conclusions about it are less reliable.

Costs

Every trade pays exchange and broker fees and the spread, and a stop loss in a fast move also pays slippage. The more often you trade and the shorter your targets, the larger the share of the move costs take. The average result of a trade before costs must be clearly above them — that is the strategy’s break-even point.

How to keep costs under control:

  • trade liquid instruments with a narrow spread (lesson How to choose an instrument);
  • enter with limit orders where the idea allows it: on many exchanges the maker pays less than the taker;
  • set targets several times larger than the round-trip costs;
  • do not trade for the sake of trading: fewer trades by your rules beat many random ones.

Fees differ by exchange, market and broker and they change — check them with your exchange and broker. The lesson Execution helps count the full cost of a trade.

Trade streaks

Even good rules produce losing streaks. Below are a hundred random trades with a 40% win rate and an average win twice the average loss: press the button to see how differently the same strategy can look.

Series of trades

First 30 series: cumulative result in R; dashed — the expectancy

Expectancy per trade
+0.20 R
Expectancy over 100 trades
+20.0 R
Series ending below zero
9.8 %
Series result: 5% · median · 95%
−4.0 · +20.0 · +44.0 R
Largest drawdown: median · 95%
10.0 · 19.0 R
Losses in a row: median · 95% · max
7 · 13 · 19

500 series; trades are independent, a win is the given number of R, a loss is 1 R. In real trading results are related, and losing streaks are usually longer.

Two rules follow: the risk per trade should be small enough that ten losses in a row do not knock you out of trading, and an approach should be judged over dozens of trades, not the last three.

Journal

Record every trade: instrument, market regime, signal, entry, stop loss, exit, result and a chart screenshot. After a few weeks the journal shows in which regime and at what time the approach works for you, and where you break your rules. A plan template is in the lesson Trading plan and journal, common mistakes are in Beginner mistakes.

In the JetScalp terminal

Summary

  • A strategy is an idea, conditions, signal, entry, risk, exit, costs and testing, written down in advance.
  • The market regime decides which approach fits: trend — with the move, range — from the boundaries, squeeze — get ready for a breakout.
  • Targets should be several times larger than costs; liquid instruments and limit orders reduce them.
  • Losing streaks are unavoidable: choose the risk per trade with a margin and judge an approach by a journal of dozens of trades.

Check yourself

  1. How does the idea “price will bounce off the level” differ from an idea that names the participants?
  2. Price stays all day on one side of a sloping VWAP. Which approach fits better here — trades from boundaries or with the trend?
  3. Why can a regime filter tuned to your last trades let you down on the next ones?
Last updated on